← Back to blog

· By the Brother Doctor team

ER, urgent care or telehealth: what each one costs

Telehealth visit with a doctor on a laptop

You wake up with a high fever, or your child twists an ankle on a Saturday, and the question comes right away: ER, urgent care or telehealth? In the U.S., the door you pick can change the bill by thousands of dollars for the same problem.

This guide shows what each one costs, using American research, and how to decide without risking your health. It is informational and does not replace a medical evaluation.

Symptoms first, price second

If the problem could threaten your life, price is not part of the decision. Call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room. The American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) lists these among the warning signs of an emergency: chest pain or pressure, trouble breathing, fainting, changes in vision, difficulty speaking and confusion.

For stroke, the CDC says to call 911 right away for sudden numbness or weakness on one side of the body, trouble speaking, sudden trouble seeing, dizziness or loss of balance, or a sudden severe headache with no known cause.

The federal EMTALA law requires the hospital to screen you and stabilize an emergency regardless of your ability to pay. That does not cancel the bill, which arrives afterwards.

What each door costs

The figures below are 2022 averages from the Health Care Cost Institute (HCCI), which analyzes employer-sponsored insurance claims. Use them as a yardstick, not as a price list for someone paying out of pocket:

  • Emergency room: $2,256 per visit on average. For a urinary tract infection, $2,511.
  • Urgent care: $220 per visit on average. For the same urinary tract infection, $218.
  • Primary care office: $224 per visit on average.

For people paying cash, consumer price sites put urgent care between $125 and $300, averaging around $180, and the ER around $2,400 to $2,600. Treat these as orders of magnitude: the real price depends on the clinic, the hospital and what is done.

For telehealth, the most cited reference is a RAND study in Health Affairs (2017): for an acute respiratory infection, an episode cost on average $79 by telehealth, $146 in a doctor's office and $1,734 in the ER. The data are from 2011 to 2013, so prices are higher today, and most telehealth visits were new use, not a swap for an in-person visit. In current self-pay price lists, a virtual visit usually runs between $40 and $90.

Why the ER costs so much

The bill has two parts: the hospital's facility fee (which covers the 24-hour infrastructure) and the physician's professional fee, billed separately. According to the Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, from 2004 to 2021 the facility fee on ER visits grew 531%, versus 132% for professional fees.

In Florida, hospitals must notify patients that physicians working there may bill separately and that you can request a more personalized estimate of charges (Fla. Stat. 395.301). Asking is your right, and worth doing.

Beware of the ER that looks like urgent care

Florida has "freestanding" emergency departments, with storefronts that resemble a clinic. A 2021 Florida legislative analysis notes that they charge a physician fee plus a hospital facility fee, that consumers sometimes mistake them for urgent care centers, and that urgent care averaged about $193 versus more than $2,000 at an emergency room.

Before you walk in, read the sign outside and ask at the front desk: "Is this a hospital emergency department or an urgent care? Do you charge an emergency room fee?"

How to choose in 30 seconds

  • Life-threatening or getting worse fast: 911 or the ER.
  • Not serious, but it cannot wait until tomorrow (a cut that needs stitches, a sprain, a painful urinary infection): urgent care.
  • Simple problem, a refill, lab results, a question: telehealth or a family clinic.
  • Ongoing problem or follow-up: a family medicine clinic, with the same clinician over time.

If you are unsure how serious it is, treat it as an emergency. According to ACEP, an emergency is defined by the symptoms that bring you in, not by the final diagnosis.

Before you pay for any of them

  • Ask for the self-pay rate before the visit.
  • For a scheduled visit, ask for a written Good Faith Estimate. The guide to seeing a doctor without insurance explains the deadlines and how to dispute a bill.
  • Ask for the itemized bill and check it line by line.
  • Ask whether the physician, lab and radiology are billed separately.

Three everyday situations

Saturday night, a child with a fever who perks up between temperature spikes. If the child drinks fluids, plays and responds, urgent care or a telehealth visit is often enough for a first evaluation. If the child is very sleepy, cannot drink, has trouble breathing, or is a very young infant, go to the ER.

Pain when urinating, no high fever and no back pain. This is the kind of complaint urgent care handles with a same-day urine test, and the same urinary tract infection averaged $218 at urgent care versus $2,511 in the ER, according to HCCI.

A prescription that ran out, or a question about a test result. Telehealth or your family clinic can handle these, with no wait and no hospital facility fee. Keep the names and doses of your medications on your phone for whichever door you use.

Where Brother Doctor fits

Brother Doctor Family Health will open its first location in the Orlando area, with its office in Winter Garden, serving patients from Winter Garden, Orlando, Winter Park and Kissimmee in English, Portuguese and Spanish, on a self-pay model, for everyday care: in-person visits, telehealth and care without health insurance. We are not an emergency room and we do not replace emergency care.

Frequently asked questions

How much does an ER visit cost in the U.S. without insurance?

On average about $2,256 per visit in employer plans (HCCI, 2022), and consumer price sites cite $2,400 to $2,600. The real amount varies widely and may arrive as separate hospital and physician bills.

Can an ER turn me away because I cannot pay?

Not for emergencies. The federal EMTALA law requires screening and stabilization regardless of ability to pay. The bill comes afterwards.

Is urgent care cheaper than the ER?

Generally yes. In 2022 the average was $220 per urgent care visit versus $2,256 in the ER (HCCI). For serious conditions, though, the ER is the right place.

How do I tell an ER from an urgent care?

Read the sign outside and ask the front desk whether it is a hospital emergency department and whether they charge an emergency room fee. In Florida, freestanding ERs can look like clinics.

What is telehealth good for?

Simple problems, prescription refills, questions and test results, with no travel. It does not replace a physical exam or emergency care.

Can I ask for the price before the visit?

Yes, and you should. Ask for the self-pay rate first, request a written estimate for a scheduled visit and ask for an itemized bill afterwards.

← Back to blog